Organization!

[seventhe]

I've updated all the memories in brokenprism so that they, uh, make a little more sense. An explanation can be found in the new profile, here.

*phew* Now, a break, and then tomorrow I really need to redo the ff_epicfic memories in a way that makes sense.

In other news: The FF Archive needs input plz!

I know a lot of my f-list is FF-fanwork-related, and I'd like you guys to chime in on this if you can. Basically, we're asking whether an FF-only, FF-based, FF-specific (as in canons, characters, etc) Fic Archive would interest anybody. Think ff.net, only better and less sucky, designed specifically for Final Fantasy writers.

Obviously, this will take a lot of work -- conceiving of a system that caters to the bizarre FF fandom and doesn't suck nuts; programming the thing; actually implementing the system and bug-testing; and then finally maintaining, running, keeping it up-to-date - not to mention modding and paying for the archive. The question is mostly: would you use it? Is it worth it?

There have already been some discussions and some developments on it, but after the FanLib fiasco and LJ's inadvertant fandom-bonding screwup, the question now is mostly: is this something that would be totally sweet?

Here: http://community.livejournal.com/ffarchive/4612.html

And now, I'm off to do actual work.

Comments

[first-seventhe.livejournal.com]

I'm assuming that it would work like fanfiction.net, right, where the authors themselves would be in charge of uploading and correctly tagging their own fic. I don't think mods would be in charge of anything other than overseeing their particular fandom area and answering to complaints (hopefully better than ff.net does).

At least, I hope not! I volunteered to be a mod!

[katmillia.livejournal.com]

I figured that it would be more like Draco and Ginny dot com, where members can post their own stories but they all go into a processing area, and then the mods, called the "Cabal" there, go through and make sure there aren't huge glaring spelling mistakes and inaccuracies so that the quality of fic is still high, and if there are, they send an email back to the author stating the needed changes. I believe they have one member on duty each day who is in charge of reading through the stories, except I think the FF one would work smoother if there were mods in charge of specific FF games, since I would know nothing about say FFVI or FFVII. I guess I just assumed this would be the way it was done. Perhaps I should mention this over there?

hooray tl;dr!

[first-seventhe.livejournal.com]

Well, if the community opens, you can read some of the back posts on stuff like this. I know a lot of different things have been suggested, too, so you might want to suggest this as well (and reference Draco and Ginny dot com).

I believe the thing that was last suggested was a kind of an archive self-policing policy. There would be a "report" button that users could use to report stories with horrible grammar / character bashing / canon mistakes / chatspeak to the fandom mod. (And yes, I believe the current plan is for each fandom to have at least ONE mod, if not more.) The mod would then review the fic and make the final decision on whether or not it was suitable for the archive.

Users whose stories were judged as "not acceptable" would then have their accounts suspended (either partially or fully; not yet decided) until they fixed their story. There would be a note from the fandom mod, explaining the reason for rejection (with reference to the site's TOS). This provides an actual incentive for users to fix their story, then!

This way, stories can be immediately submitted to the site, so you don't have to wait for a mod to review it before it actually gets posted. At the same time, there are two checks and balances: one being the "report" function that any user can use to ping a mod, and two being the mod actually checking the story that has been pinged and deciding whether the story is at fault (Author A suspended) or whether it was a false report (User B suspended temporarily for report abuse).

Again, this was just something that was discussed, not necessarily decided on... feel free to go and add your two cents on everything, basically!

Re: hooray tl;dr!

[katmillia.livejournal.com]

This makes sense, and I suppose it makes it so people aren't needed to be online for 12 hours or so on their modding day to approve entries. I just hope something like this actually gets going- because having an ff archive that is full of fic would make me a happy camper! :D

Re: hooray tl;dr!

[first-seventhe.livejournal.com]

Yeah, it's kind of the fairest way for both the mods and the users. And I think some kind of system that would rank the stories based on offense - a story that had been reported 10 times would go before one with only one flag - would be useful as well. XD

I would love for this to go through, honestly!